Cooking Appliances review
Lodge 12-inch Cast Iron Review: One Lab Calls It Poor, and It Is Still Worth Buying
Two reviewers who both measured it reached opposite verdicts. The disagreement is not really about the pan, it is about whether even heating or heat retention matters more to you.
By Paulo GerchonPublished 2 min read
Illustration, not a photo — we don’t have a licensed image of this product yet.
Lodge
Lodge Classic Cast Iron Skillet 12 in
Good · researched from 4 sources
Buy it for searing, roasting and anything you finish in the oven, where the thermal mass does the work. Do not buy it expecting an evenly heated pan, because the one reviewer who scored that specifically gave it two out of five.
- Buy if
- Searing steak, and anything that goes from hob to oven · Cooks who want one pan that outlives them · Gas hobs, where the hot spot problem is smallest
- Skip if
- Glass-top stoves, on Prudent Reviews' explicit warning · Delicate even-heat cooking like crepes or thin omelettes · Anyone who will not maintain seasoning
We don’t list prices, because Amazon’s change hourly.
The two reviews point in opposite directions
Prudent Reviews used one for more than five years, measured it holding water at 124F after five minutes against 118 to 120F for competing skillets, and made it their number one recommendation.
Century Life scored its even heating 2 out of 5, described hot spots sitting directly over the burner unless you have a high-end gas range, and rated the pan 2.35 out of 5 overall.
Neither is wrong, and the gap between them is the most useful thing here.
Cast iron has enormous thermal mass and poor conductivity. Mass means it holds temperature when a cold steak hits it, which is exactly what searing needs. Poor conductivity means the heat sits where the flame is and takes minutes to crawl outward, which is exactly what a crepe does not want.
Prudent measured the first property. Century Life measured the second. Which review is right for you depends on what you cook.
What the texture is for
The casting is rough. Century Life describes it as somewhat bumpy and treats it as a compromise that helps seasoning stick while needing many layers to become semi-nonstick.
Prudent Reviews reads the same texture as a feature, crediting the tiny bumps with gripping meat and giving the pan its searing and browning advantage over smoother vintage cast iron.
Both descriptions match the object. The pan is not smooth, and whether that is a flaw depends on whether you are browning a steak or sliding an egg.
The numbers that surprise people
Century Life weighed it at 3730 grams and measured the flat cooking circle at 10 inches, against a 12 inch rim. The walls flare, so the number on the box is the widest point rather than the useful one.
Prudent Reviews puts it at 8.1 pounds. At that weight the helper handle opposite the main one stops being a nicety.
What it asks of you
Season it, probably before the first cook. Prudent found factory seasoning inconsistent enough that it often needed redoing, and their method is 450 to 500F for an hour.
Do not soak it. Do not put it in the dishwasher. Dry it properly, because rust removal means a metal scouring pad and starting the seasoning again.
Use a potholder every single time. Prudent's specific complaint is that the silicone handle cover Lodge includes slides off too easily.
And keep it off a glass hob. Prudent is direct that the coarse base damages them, and eight pounds of textured iron on ceramic is not a fight the ceramic wins.
How it scored
The overall 7.9 is the weighted average of these five criteria — we never adjust it by hand.
Cooking performance
Prudent Reviews credits the textured surface with superior searing and browning. Century Life scores even heating 2 out of 5 and reports hot spots directly over the burner.
Value
Prudent Reviews makes it their number one recommendation on durability and price after more than five years of use.
Build quality
Effectively indestructible, though Prudent Reviews found factory seasoning inconsistent, either uneven or thin enough to need redoing before first use.
Ease of use
8.1 lb per Prudent Reviews, a handle that gets extremely hot, and a coarse base that Prudent warns damages glass-top stoves.
Heat retention
Prudent Reviews measured water at 124F after five minutes against 118 to 120F for competing skillets.
Pros and cons
What we liked
- Prudent Reviews measured the best heat retention in their comparison, 124F against 118 to 120F
- The rough casting grips meat, which Prudent Reviews credits for its searing
- A helper handle opposite the main one, which matters at this weight
- Cheap enough that Prudent Reviews calls it their number one recommendation
- Effectively unbreakable, with no coating to fail
What we didn’t
- Century Life scored even heating 2 out of 5 and rated the pan 2.35 out of 5 overall
- At 8.1 lb it is genuinely heavy to move one-handed
- The handle gets extremely hot, and Prudent found the supplied silicone grip slides off
- Prudent Reviews found factory seasoning inconsistent, often needing redoing before first use
- Century Life measured the usable cooking circle at 10 inches, not the 12 on the label
- Prudent warns the coarse base damages glass-top stoves
Specifications
| Weight | 8.1 lb per Prudent Reviews; 3730 g measured by Century Life |
|---|---|
| Rim diameter | 12 in |
| Cooking surface | About 10 in per Century Life |
| Sidewall thickness | About 5 mm per Century Life |
| Heat retention | Water at 124F after 5 minutes per Prudent Reviews |
| Seasoning | Factory seasoned with vegetable oil |
| Handles | Main handle plus helper handle |
| Re-seasoning | 450 to 500F for one hour per Prudent Reviews |
How we researched this
We have not had this unit on the bench. This review synthesises the manufacturer’s published specifications, independent measurements and owner reports listed below. Every figure on this page comes from one of those sources rather than our own measurement.
4
sources reviewed
Prudent Reviews and Century Life both measured and reached opposite conclusions, which is why this review reports the disagreement rather than a verdict. Prudent supplies the weight, the heat retention comparison and the five year durability observations. Century Life supplies the measured cooking surface, the sidewall thickness and the even-heating score, and is the dissenting voice. Mr Cast Iron contributed the handle and seasoning observations from ordinary use and sits between the two. Lodge's own page was not read, so every figure is attributed to a reviewer.
What we read
Common questions
Why do two reviewers disagree so completely about the Lodge skillet?
Is the cooking surface really 12 inches?
Do I need to season it before first use?
How hot does the handle get?
Can I use it on a glass-top stove?
The bottom line on the Lodge Classic Cast Iron Skillet 12 in
Buy it for searing, roasting and anything you finish in the oven, where the thermal mass does the work. Do not buy it expecting an evenly heated pan, because the one reviewer who scored that specifically gave it two out of five.
More home & kitchen reviews
Cooking Appliances
Anova Precision Cooker 3.0
The temperature control is as good as any lab has measured on a domestic circulator. The one thing everybody complains about is a timer that starts before you put the food in.
Cooking Appliances
Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro
One lab ranked it first of eleven and gave its interface a perfect ten. It also measured the temperature running five degrees hot, which matters more for baking than for anything else it does.
Cooking Appliances
Instant Pot Duo 7-in-1
It is not rated for pressure canning low-acid food, which is the one thing worth knowing before you trust it with anything. Everything else it does well enough to replace four appliances.